Mac's Stuffed Cookies

Build Your Own Stuffed Cookie: The Best Filling and Topping Pairings

Six stuffed cookies with different fillings and premium toppings baked together in a tin

Every cookie on our page can be built your way: you choose the dough, the filling inside and the topping. Lots of choice is great, until you have to decide. Here are the combinations we keep coming back to.

The three choices

  • Dough: golden butter (sweet and buttery), double chocolate (rich and dark) or red velvet (soft, with a hint of cocoa)
  • Filling: Nutella, Biscoff spread, pistachio cream, cookies and cream, white chocolate cream, salted caramel or dark chocolate ganache
  • Topping: chocolate chunks, broken biscuits, white chocolate, chopped pistachios, icing sugar, sea salt, or a premium topping

Our favourite pairings

For chocolate lovers

The crowd pleaser

For the caramel crowd

The fancy one

The surprise

For kids

A few tips

  • One strong flavour at a time. If the filling is bold (ganache, pistachio), keep the topping simple.
  • Add contrast. A salty or crunchy topping makes a sweet filling taste even better.
  • Mix it up in a tin or box. With six cookies, go for one of each, or three pairs of two favourites.
  • Check allergens. Pistachio fillings and toppings add tree nuts, and Nutella adds hazelnut. Each cookie shows what it contains as you build it.

Premium toppings

In the Loaded Tin and the Cookie Box, premium toppings are included free: Belgian chocolate shards with edible gold, salted caramel and toffee shards, pistachio cream with whole pistachios, white chocolate with raspberry, and more.

Start building

Head to Mac's Stuffed Cookies and build your own, one cookie at a time.

Big, thick, stuffed cookies, built your way.

Build your cookies →

More from the blog